Last week, I went to George Mason University to speak to 300 Girl Scouts (12-16 years old) that were participating in the Girl Scout Leadership Conference for Latinas. My topics were nutrition and celebrating size diversity. While the talk went as expected, I couldn’t believe the questions I got at the end. It honestly has me worried about what kind of messages are already in these girls heads and how sad American “thinness” culture has really become. Read on and let me know what YOU think.
Nutrition
These girls are young. I knew nutrition had to be about them interacting with food and learning about putting foods together for balanced meals. (Let’s face it. I had trouble learning about “fiber” in college. Certainly a 12 year old doesn’t need to hear how fruit has fiber and how that will help them take a poop.) We all learn better by “doing” right? So I decided we would make two salsas, one veggie, one fruit and then combine the salsas with a grain to make a meal! We also worked with herbs and using salt as a seasoning.
This was fun and I thought it was effective.
I also taught them how they can combine foods for a balanced meal. I gave them one piece of advice about eating habits: eat when you feel hungry. If you find yourself wanting to eat and you aren’t hungry at all, it is probably a good idea to wait awhile until you feel hungry.
I quizzed them after about ideas for putting together a balanced plate for energy and health and they aced it.

Girl scout making a fruit and veggie salsa.
So far so good… I thought.
Body Image
Oy. I was honestly worried about this. But then I got some great advice from colleagues at “Health at Every Size” There is a game called “if I had a quarter”. Basically you can “buy” traits you are looking for in a friend. There are about 20 traits, some are body focused and others are character focused. They all did good “answering” basically what they knew I wanted them to hear. I still wasn’t surprised thinking well Latinas celebrate their shapes so maybe body image is not such an issue with them.
I also talked about Serena Williams (a former girl scout) with them who has been quoted as saying her favorite “feature” is her smile because a smile lights up your life and others. I thought that was great. The talk ended and I felt they were as engaged as a group of 300 girls can be before lunch on a hot, muggy D.C. day.
The Aftermath
There was time for q/a and that’s where all hell broke lose. The first question I got was “can I eat six small meals a day to boost my metabolism?” My brain responded “what, are you kidding me? how do you know what metabolism is and what part of my talk indicated that it was smart to manipulate eating habits to “boost” your metabolism?” Then I felt like I had an “out of body experience” I was suddenly 13 years old again trying one of my mom’s diet shakes, doing exercise videos for “buns of steel”, and looking forward to read the next month issue of a “health” magazine. Then my brain said “duh. you’ve been here Beck. everything old is new again.” I got sad for a second, but I didn’t have any time for that. I answered. “Why do you want to boost your metabolism?” She said “to lose weight”. My brain: “damn.” So I said “How do you know that weight loss would be healthy for you?” She stared at me. After an uncomfortable pause, I said “You know, the best thing you can do for nutrition right now is to listen more to your body. When you feel hungry, that’s your body telling you to eat. You should listen to that. One day it may talk to you six times, another day only three or four. Can you do that?” She said “OK”. I was as satisfied as I could be with that interaction, but something makes me feel like she didn’t really like my answer or believe it.
Next question: “Will cardio help me boost my metabolism?” My brain: “What the… here we go with metabolism again.” Then I was transported to the 16-year-old me who saved my money for a gym membership “Bodyworks!” Oh how I learned mastering the Stairmaster, watch the time tick down and calorie burn tick up. I asked “What do you mean cardio?” Totally testing her. I wanted to make the conversation about some type of tangible movement and activity. She said “running”. My brain “cool. I’ll take running. After all I’m a runner!” I asked “Why do you want to boost your metabolism?” Guess what she said…. “To lose weight.” My brain “Get off the stage now. You are making no difference. We’re all f-ed.” I sucked it up and answered “Did you know something? Exercise is very important. We should play, get involved in team or individual sports (there’s a lack of girls in sports), and have fun outside. When you exercise you feel better, you sleep better, you have a better chance at doing well in school, which will help you be a better leader in the future. (this was a leadership even BTW) But one thing exercise is not good for is weight loss. Don’t worry about “metabolism” girls. Look for activities you might enjoy and have fun with exercise.” I looked at the clock and it was 11 a.m. on the nose. Time for me stop and them to go eat. I felt saved by the bell. I honestly don’t know if my heart could take more disappointment.
What Say You?
Do you have any stories to share about your past experiences or working with girls these days? Your daughters? I have three nieces and lots of little girls in my life. I’m totally in fantasyland thinking that they won’t go through what I went through, aren’t I?
I guess that is why I do what I do. As much as #mefirst is about self-care… the idea is so you can better take care of others, including the younger people in your life. What do you say to help them shape their thoughts about themselves?
I can’t wait for “America The Beautiful 2″ to come out. If you haven’t seen the first one you can watch it on Hulu for free. Part two is all about dieting. I think it can’t come soon enough.













